Oklahoma Law Requires Judges to Waive Court Debt for Low-Income Defendants, but Some Judges Refuse
A 2023 Oklahoma law requires judges to reduce or waive court debt for defendants who receive certain government assistance, such as food stamps, or who earn significantly below the poverty level. Some judges are not applying it, KOSU and The Frontier reported on October 26, 2026.
According to the report, Archie Riley, 67, owes $1,358 in court debt. In July, Oklahoma County Special District Judge April Collins denied his request for a waiver despite "sufficient evidence of a current inability to pay" and entered a judgment against him instead. Legal Aid Services of Oklahoma is challenging that decision at the Oklahoma Supreme Court. Collins argues the law is unconstitutional because the state constitution bars the Legislature from wiping away debt owed to the state, counties or cities. Arguments went before a Supreme Court referee in September. While the challenge is pending, Oklahoma County is not waiving any fines or fees.
Trial court administrator Renée Troxell said, "Judges enter rulings based on the way they believe the law reads." Anthony Severin of Still She Rises said of the law, "It is a path out of a vicious cycle," and said mechanisms such as expungement and drug court could also be at risk depending on the outcome.
Practices differ by county. The report said Cleveland County Judge Michael Tupper waived more than $10,000 in one February hearing, and Pottawatomie County Judge John Canavan waived more than $97,000 for 10 defendants in November 2025. As of October 19, Legal Aid had helped clients obtain more than $2.1 million in waivers, but it has only four attorneys handling cost hearings. Ed Wunch of Legal Aid said at least 14 counties are unlikely to grant relief without a lawyer. Another defendant, Jonathan Fuller, owes nearly $3,000 and has attended nine cost hearings since 2019; community service would reduce his debt by $45 per hour.
Why it matters: Unpaid court debt can lead to warrants, license problems and repeated court appearances. The Oklahoma Supreme Court's decision could determine whether low-income Oklahomans statewide can obtain relief under the 2023 law.
Source: KOSU / The Frontier, "Oklahoma law requires judges to waive court debt for poor defendants. Some refuse." (Oct. 26, 2026). https://www.kosu.org/oklahoma-waiving-court-debt
This update is for general information only and is not legal advice.





Comments