top of page

Advocate's Corner: Joseph T. Holmes Jr. #443554

Oct 25
4 min read

If the Evidence Proves Guilt, Why Not Let It Be Examined?

In 2003, in a case prosecuted by Assistant District Attorney Tim S. Braley, a Garfield County jury convicted Joseph T. Holmes Jr. of Second Degree Murder in Case No. CF-2001-527. On May 9, 2003, District Judge Richard M. Perry sentenced him to life with the possibility of parole. He pleaded not guilty, and he has maintained his innocence for more than two decades. According to court filings, the evidence used to convict him has been in the State's possession since 2006, and no defense expert has been allowed to examine it.

The Case

According to court filings, the State's case turned on one central question: which firearm fired the fatal shot. The State argued that the bullet came from a .22 caliber Jennings semiautomatic pistol linked to Mr. Holmes. The defense has long argued that the medical evidence points to a different kind of weapon, a rifle.

The Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals affirmed his conviction on direct appeal in 2004. Over the years that followed, Mr. Holmes filed several post-conviction applications on his own, without a lawyer, and each was denied or dismissed. His filings argue that his trial attorney never hired an independent ballistics expert to test the State's theory about the weapon.

The Forensic Questions

The pathologist. According to court filings, Assistant Medical Examiner Dr. Chai Choi reviewed an X-ray that showed a "lead snowstorm," a scattering of bullet fragments. At trial she testified that the X-ray showed a "suggestion of high power" and that "it could have been that of... a rifle." She also testified that she could not decide between a handgun and a rifle. The defense states that before trial, Dr. Choi gave defense counsel textbook pages describing a lead snowstorm as a sign of a high-powered rifle. The filings also state that a licensed private investigator interviewed Dr. Choi in July 2002 and that she expressed the opinion that the wound was likely caused by a high-powered rifle and not a pistol. At trial, she denied saying that.

The OSBI examiner. According to court filings, OSBI Senior Criminalist Gordon Robertson testified that he could neither positively identify nor eliminate the Jennings pistol as the weapon that fired the fatal bullet. "It may have been fired from the pistol, but it may not have," he testified, explaining that the bullet was too damaged for a conclusive comparison. He did exclude one .22 caliber rifle, State's Exhibit 55, as the weapon that fired the fatal bullet. On cross-examination, he agreed with a leading forensic textbook that a lead snowstorm on an X-ray "suggests that the bullet was delivered by a high-powered rifle," adding that "it does not happen in every case."

The defense position. Mr. Holmes's filings argue that the Jennings pistol, firing .22 caliber ammunition from 20 to 30 yards, could not have produced a lead snowstorm. If a rifle fired the fatal shot, the defense argues, the State's own theory would exclude him as the shooter. The trial testimony did not settle that question. That is exactly why the defense says the evidence must be examined.

The Evidence He Has Never Been Allowed to Examine

According to court filings, the trial exhibits admitted by the State were returned to the State on September 13, 2006. In July 2022, Mr. Holmes's attorney wrote to Garfield County District Attorney Mike Fields asking for access to the exhibits, and Assistant District Attorney Shawn Hill refused.

In August 2022, a motion for access to the trial exhibits was filed. At a hearing on September 12, 2022, District Judge Tom L. Newby denied the request and directed the State, through Assistant District Attorney Tyler Foster, to prepare a written order. According to the filings, that written order was never prepared, even after a reminder from defense counsel. Without a certified written order, Mr. Holmes could not ask the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals to review the decision.

Actual Innocence Application and Motion for Access

On October 31, 2022, Mr. Holmes filed a Successor Application for Post-Conviction Relief asking the Garfield County District Court to vacate his conviction based on actual innocence. On the same day, he filed an Amended Motion for Access to the State's Evidence Introduced at Trial. That motion asks that a defense ballistics expert be allowed to examine the pistol, the rifle, the bullets, the cartridge casings and the crime scene charts.

The defense expert, Lance Martini, stated in a sworn affidavit that he cannot reach any conclusions without examining that evidence.

Still Waiting

According to Mr. Holmes, as of October 2026 the Garfield County District Attorney has not responded to either the actual innocence application or the amended motion for access to the trial evidence. That is nearly four years without an answer.

Why We Advocate

All In One, Inc. believes in a justice system that is fair, transparent and accountable to the facts. We do not appear in court on anyone's behalf, and we do not decide guilt or innocence. We believe that questions this serious should be answered with evidence.

Oklahoma has seen cases where examining evidence after trial changed the outcome. Mr. Holmes's case raises a simple question: if the evidence proves guilt, why not let it be examined? Allowing an independent expert to review the trial evidence serves everyone, including the people harmed by crime, because it brings the truth into the light.

To learn more, write a letter of support, or stand with Joseph as an advocate, contact admin@allinoneinc.org.

This profile summarizes public court records filed in Garfield County District Court Case No. CF-2001-527 and statements provided by Mr. Holmes. Statements about the evidence and the proceedings are drawn from those filings and reflect the positions taken in them; they are not findings by any court. All In One, Inc. is a nonprofit organization that does not appear in court on anyone's behalf, does not provide legal advice, and does not support or oppose any candidate for public office. Mr. Holmes consented to the publication of his name, story, and photo.

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page