top of page

Advocate's Corner: Moses H. Metoyer Muhammad Asks Oklahoma Supreme Court to Order Pre-1998 Parole Review (Case No. 124,517)

7 days ago
4 min read

All In One, Inc. is sharing information about a filing by Moses H. Metoyer Muhammad (Wadress H. Metoyer Jr.) for people in Oklahoma Department of Corrections custody for crimes committed before July 1, 1998, and their families.

Mr. Muhammad is 77 years old and remains in Department of Corrections custody. According to his filing, the offense was committed before July 1, 1998.

What he filed

He has taken the matter to the Oklahoma Supreme Court in a pro se Application to Assume Original Jurisdiction and Petition for Writ of Mandamus, identified here as Case No. 124,517. The respondents are members of the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board.

What a writ of mandamus is

A writ of mandamus is a court order directing a public agency to perform a duty the law requires. His petition argues that a writ of mandamus is the appropriate and only adequate remedy, and he asks the Court to use that writ to compel the Board to perform duties his filing describes as mandatory.

Why the case is in the Supreme Court

His filing cites Article VII, Section 4 of the Oklahoma Constitution as the basis for bringing the case in the Supreme Court. That provision extends the Court's general superintending control over agencies, commissions, and boards created by law. His petition also cites Article VI, Section 10 and contends that the Board is a state agency charged with mandatory duties under that provision and under Title 57 of the Oklahoma Statutes.

The law his petition cites for crimes committed before July 1, 1998

His filing points to 57 O.S. § 332.7, including subsections F, G and O, which House Bill 1213 (1997), the Truth in Sentencing Act (Laws 1997, c. 133), first amended to add these rules and which House Bill 2286 (2018) and House Bill 4369 (2022) later amended. According to his petition, those provisions establish procedures for people whose offenses were committed before July 1, 1998. Those procedures, his petition states, require the Board to determine what sentence the person would have received under the 1997 sentencing matrices, identified in the filing as Sections 598 through 601, Chapter 133, O.S.L. 1997, and to examine applications on the merits.

His petition argues that the word "shall" in those provisions imposes a mandatory duty on the Board, not a discretionary one. His filing also states that a commutation application was submitted through counsel under 57 O.S. § 332.2(A) and (H), and that this application put the Board on notice that continued incarceration was excessive under the statutory framework applicable to offenses committed before July 1, 1998.

What his petition states about the Board's denial, time served, and staff reports

His filing states that the Oklahoma Pardon and Parole Board denied that application on August 10, 2026, and that a notice of the denial was signed on September 1, 2026. His petition says the denial did not examine the merits under the provisions that govern crimes committed before July 1, 1998, did not make the required matrix sentence determination under subsections F, G and O of 57 O.S. § 332.7, and did not conduct an impartial review based on the staff reports.

The 1997 Truth in Sentencing Act defined a life sentence as 18 to 60 years, the range his petition cites. His petition states that he has served well beyond one-third of his sentence, and beyond 85 percent of the midpoint of that range.

According to his filing, three Board staff investigative reports recommended parole. A report completed September 25, 2018, recommended parole. A report completed October 11, 2024, recommended parole with a 180-day step-down to minimum security. A report completed October 11, 2025, recommended parole, with eligibility based on one-third time for a crime committed before July 1, 1998. According to those reports, as his petition describes them, he has been incarcerated since 1983, has completed all required programs and assessed needs, has earned an associate's degree, has had seven misconducts, none involving violence, and has had no misconduct reports since 2016.

What he asks the Court to order

His petition asks the Court to direct the Board to do four things. First, examine the merits of his application for commutation or parole in accordance with its mandatory statutory duties. Second, apply the provisions that govern crimes committed before July 1, 1998. Third, make the required determination of what sentence he would have received under the 1997 matrix provisions, using the 18-to-60-year range his petition cites. Fourth, conduct an impartial review based on completed investigative reports prepared by Board staff.

In his prayer for relief, he asks the Court to assume original jurisdiction and to issue a writ of mandamus.

Why this filing may matter to others

If the Court agrees with his petition, a ruling could clarify how the Board handles applications from people still in Department of Corrections custody for offenses committed before July 1, 1998, not only his. That question may matter to others in custody for those offenses, and to their families.

Keep a close watch on this ruling

Keep a close watch on this ruling. We will keep you updated with the latest developments. Follow Case No. 124,517 on the Oklahoma State Courts Network. For questions about this matter, write All In One, Inc. at admin@allinoneinc.org, the only contact for this post.

General information, not legal advice.

Sources

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page